| |

A New Leader’s First Job Isn’t Proving Yourself : It’s Building Alliances

Have you ever noticed what happens when someone is promoted into leadership?

They often become more determined to prove themselves.

They speak more quickly. They offer answers before fully understanding the question. They arrive with plans, priorities and perhaps a few changes they have been waiting to make.

It is understandable. A new leader wants people to see that the promotion was justified.

But what if proving competence is not the first job?

What if the first job is to build the relationships that will make competent leadership possible?

This is one of the patterns I've noticed repeatedly in my coaching work. People rarely struggle in a new leadership role because they lack skill. They struggle because they are trying to lead through authority before they have established trust.

The result can be stressful and exhausting.

They feel they need to know everything. Their team waits for instructions rather than offering ideas. Colleagues become cautious. Decisions take longer because people are unsure what the new leader really wants.

So perhaps the better question is not, “How do I prove I am good enough to lead?”

Perhaps it is:

“How do I become someone people can work with, rely on and speak honestly to?”

That is where alliances begin.

Leadership is bigger than the people I manage

In Lead with Confidence, I describe five principles through the A-CODE model:

  • Alliances
  • Confidence
  • Order
  • Direction
  • Energy

Alliances comes first for a reason.

A leader with no team is not really a leader. And by “team”, I don't mean only the people who report directly to you.

A leader needs relationships with their own manager, peers, customers, suppliers, senior stakeholders and people in other departments. They may need someone’s knowledge, support, approval, challenge or cooperation before they can make meaningful progress.

Many hands make light work. It is an old expression, but there is something useful in it.

Leadership isn't about carrying every problem alone (although new leaders often feel they have to). It is about creating enough trust and connection for people to call on you and be there for you so that together you can make meaningful contributions.

An alliance is more than networking. It suggests mutual benefit.

The relationship should make both sides stronger.

A stakeholder map being drawn by two people, with connections forming between circles

Why the urge to prove yourself can get in the way

When someone gets a promotion, their identity can become slightly confused.

Am I still the person who was excellent at the technical work? the work that got me the promotion?

Or am I now responsible for something different that I'm less experienced at? Helping other people do excellent work.

Those are different roles.

The temptation is to keep showing that you can do the old job. Answering every question.  Correcting every detail. Taking work back because it feels faster to do it yourself.

But what identity does that reinforce?

It can feel comforting and secure. It tells you that you're valuable because you are busy and have all the answers.

But it's a difficult identity to maintain as a leader. There will always be someone with more technical knowledge, more history or more experience in a particular area.

Authority doesn't come from knowing everything.

It comes from being clear about what you know, honest about what you don't, and able to guide and direct those with knowledge in areas that contribute to your goals as a leader.

A new leader who says, “I'm not sure yet but let me find out,” may create more trust and confidence than someone who bluffs that they know what to do.

This is not an argument for being passive or unprepared. Competence matters. Results matter. Decisions matter.

But trust is built through the combination of character and competence.

Trust is something people experience

In my article, Trust Me, I’m a Leader, I explore trust as a belief in someone’s reliability, truth and ability.

That definition is useful because it brings trust down to earth.

People do not trust me because I have a leadership title. They trust me because of what they repeatedly experience when working with me.

Do I listen?

Do I tell the truth, even when it is uncomfortable?

Do I do what I said I would do?

Do I make decisions fairly?

Do I care about the impact of my decisions on other people?

Can I admit a mistake without becoming defensive?

Can I make a decision when one is needed?

These small experiences become a kind of evidence.

I may say that I value openness, but do people feel able to challenge me? I may say that I trust my team, but do I allow them to make decisions without checking every detail?

The words matter less than the pattern.

What alliances look like in practice

Building alliances does not require becoming political, charming or artificially sociable.

It starts with genuine curiosity.

When coaching clients in new roles we generate ideas for initial conversations with key people. They might ask:

  • What is working well that I should be careful not to break?
  • What is making your work harder than it needs to be?
  • What do you need from my team?
  • What do you think I need to understand about this organisation?
  • Where could we help each other?
  • What would you change if you were in my position?

These questions communicate that you're not arriving with the belief that your promotion has made you the most knowledgeable person in the room.

You're still responsible for leading. But you are willing to broaden your view and learn the landscape before deciding where to walk.

A good leader also listens for the things people do not say directly.

  • Who is under pressure?
  • Who has influence without a formal title?
  • Which teams have been disappointed before?
  • Where has trust been damaged by previous decisions?
  • What does success mean to different people?

This is not information gathering for its own sake. It helps you make better decisions.

If you understand the pressures and priorities around a decision, you can explain it more clearly. You can involve the right people earlier and anticipate resistance without treating resistance as disloyalty.

That is the beginning of leadership maturity and leadership effectiveness.

A simple exercise for your first month

Take a blank sheet of paper and place your name in the centre.

Around it, add the people and groups who affect your ability to lead:

  • Your manager
  • Direct reports
  • Peers
  • Senior stakeholders
  • Customers or clients
  • Other departments
  • Informal influencers
  • People whose expertise you might need

Then, beside each name, ask three questions:

  1. What matters to them?
  2. What do they currently experience when working with me and my team?
  3. What would make this relationship more useful for both of us?

This isn't about creating a list of people you can use.

You are looking for places where mutual benefit may already exist but has not yet been discussed.

One further question is worth adding:

Where am I trying to prove something instead of building something?

That question can be really helpful for highlighting where you are insecure and focused on your own fears rather than being focused on the positive impact you can have.

Maybe you're avoiding a conversation because you want to appear certain. Perhaps you are withholding a decision until you have complete agreement. Perhaps you're working late to demonstrate commitment when what the team actually needs is a clearer priority.

Alliances need systems, not good intentions

There is a limitation to all of this.

You can't build trust through one thoughtful conversation and then return to unreliable behaviour. Alliances depend on consistency.

This is where the other parts of A-CODE become important.

Confidence helps you act before you feel perfectly ready.

Order helps you create reliable habits around communication, follow-through and delegation.

Direction helps explain what we are trying to achieve and why.

Energy affects the quality of your presence. If you are permanently distracted, rushed or depleted, people will experience that, even if your words sound supportive.

Good intentions need systems around them.

If you promise to follow up, you need a way to remember. If you say you want honest feedback, you need a regular space for it. If you want people to take ownership, you need to stop stepping in at the first sign of difficulty.

This is why leadership is not simply about personality.

It is also about the structures that make dependable behaviour more natural.

The Clarity Gap behind the struggle

Sometimes a new leader thinks the problem is confidence.

“I do not feel confident enough to lead.”

But confidence may not be the whole story.

The Clarity Gap Assessment looks at three areas: Vision, Systems and Confidence.

All three matter when building alliances.

If my Vision is unclear, people may not understand what we are working towards. Every decision feels personal because there is no shared direction to refer back to.

If my Systems are weak, I may communicate inconsistently, forget commitments or create confusion through changing priorities.

If my Confidence is under strain, I may overcompensate by becoming controlling, defensive or determined to appear certain.

So what if the leadership issue is not simply, “I need more confidence”?

What if I need to notice which part of the gap is creating the difficulty?

A clearer vision may make a difficult decision easier. A better system may help me follow through. A more useful definition of confidence may allow me to admit what I am still learning.

As I wrote in The Proven Clarity Gap Framework, many business problems are thinking problems before they become action problems.

That may be true of leadership relationships too.

Common mistakes new leaders make

A few patterns appear often:

Trying to change everything immediately

Change may be necessary, but do I understand what is already working?

Before making changes, ask, “What do I need to learn first?”

Confusing consultation with weakness

Asking for input does not mean surrendering responsibility. I can listen carefully and still make the final decision.

Overpromising

A new leader may want to impress people by agreeing to everything. But an alliance is damaged when commitments are repeatedly missed.

It is better to make fewer promises and keep them.

Treating disagreement as a threat

If people challenge me, could they be protecting the quality of the decision?

The question is not, “How do I stop resistance?” It may be, “What is this resistance trying to tell me?”

Staying too close to the old identity

I may have been promoted because I was excellent at solving problems personally. I am now being asked to create the conditions for other people to solve them well.

That requires a different definition of success.

Questions to take into a conversation

Before your next one-to-one or stakeholder meeting, you might consider:

  • What do I want this person to experience when working with me?
  • What assumptions am I making about what they think of my promotion?
  • What would I hear if I listened without preparing my reply?
  • Where do I need their cooperation rather than their compliance?
  • What decision would become clearer if I understood their perspective?
  • What repeated action would help this person rely on me?

You don't need perfect answers.

You just need better questions.

Frequently asked questions

Should a new leader avoid making decisions while building alliances?

No. Building alliances is not a reason to delay necessary decisions. It is a way of making better decisions with a clearer understanding of the people and context involved.

What if people don't trust me because I'm new?

Trust may take time. You can't force it through a speech or a team away-day. You can create evidence through honesty, fairness, listening and consistent follow-through.

Do I need to be naturally outgoing to build alliances?

No. Alliances are built through attention and reliability, not performance. A thoughtful conversation can be more valuable than a room full of introductions.

What if I genuinely know more than the people around me?

Then use that knowledge in service of the team. Share it, develop others and make the reasoning behind decisions visible. Expertise becomes leadership when it helps other people contribute and grow.

A notebook, compass and simple symbols representing vision, systems and confidence

Perhaps the first test of any new leadership role is not whether you can prove you deserve the role.

Perhaps it is whether you can help the people around you feel that we are working towards something worthwhile, with someone they can rely on.

If you'd like to explore more, begin with the Clarity Gap Assessment. It may help you notice whether the main challenge is your vision, systems, confidence, or the assumptions connecting them.

Bonus question:

What alliance would make the next important decision easier?

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.